索赔证实市场研究

索赔证实市场研究

SIS 国际市场研究与战略


Claim substantiation market research responds to a current business need. Today, claims should be backed up by supporting evidence if companies expect to gain consumers’ trust and sustain the effectiveness of their products and services with factual data.

Without solid evidence backing your marketing promises, you’re essentially walking a tightrope without a safety net. One challenge from a competitor or regulator, and your entire campaign crumbles. That’s where claim substantiation market research comes in—not as a boring compliance exercise, but as your secret weapon for building unshakeable marketing campaigns.

What Is Claim Substantiation Market Research?

Regulators are watching, competitors are lurking, and consumers are savvier than ever about calling out exaggerated promises.

Claim substantiation market research involves rigorous testing, consumer studies, and scientific analysis to validate what you’re promising. The methodology varies depending on your industry and specific claims, but the goal remains constant: bulletproof evidence.

Here’s what makes claim substantiation market research different from typical market research. Instead of just understanding consumer preferences or market trends, you’re building a legal and scientific foundation for every promise you make. This research must meet specific standards set by regulatory bodies, making it far more rigorous than standard consumer surveys.

索赔证实市场研究的重要性

由于公司更加重视索赔证实以维护其声誉并赢得消费者的信任,因此近年来对索赔证实市场研究的需求猛增。

This type of research relies on solid and provides the evidence and insights businesses need to back up their claims and improve their marketing efforts. Claim substantiation market research assists businesses in establishing trust with customers, differentiating their goods and services and improving the quality of their marketing efforts.

It prevents potential legal and regulatory issues by supplying those businesses with the facts and insights they need to substantiate their claims. This enables businesses to go a step further and deliver stronger marketing campaigns with relevant and credible data.

索赔证实市场研究:数据收集和分析方法

声明证实市场研究收集并分析来自各种来源的数据来支持广告和营销声明,收集和分析数据的常用技术包括:

  • 调查: Surveys are often used to gather consumer information and support claims from the perspective of a significant market segment.
  • 专门小组: Focus groups deliver highly relevant qualitative data and allow companies to find out what their target audience really feels about their brand, products, and services.
  • 二次研究: This requires scanning through business journals and university studies for relevant information. It is applicable in case it exists a previous public study on the topic.

索赔证实市场研究:主要市场

索赔证实市场研究的主要市场包括:

  • 消费品: Businesses in the consumer goods sector frequently make bold claims about the positive health, energy, and performance outcomes that may be achieved through using their products.
  • 药品: Pharmaceutical companies must validate the claims they make about the safety and efficacy of their drugs. In this sector, it is particularly important to have enough data to back up every statement because of all the government regulations that are imposed on the healthcare industry.
  • 食品与饮品: Businesses in the food and beverage industry must provide evidence to support claims about the safety, nutritional value, and quality of their wares because it is also a highly regulated industry.
  • 化妆品: Companies in the cosmetics and personal care industry often make excessive claims about the results consumers might expect from their products. However, without proper research, it might affect the brand and customer loyalty if products do not meet consumers’ expectations.
  • Advertising: Advertising and marketing companies also research to validate the claims in their advertisements because making an overstated claim can lead to legal implications in some markets.
Claim Substantiation Cases by Industry Sector

Claim Substantiation Cases by Industry Sector

NAD Case Distribution Analysis
Data Source: Based on National Advertising Division (NAD) case analysis covering 90 cases between August 2017-July 2018, supplemented by Baker & Hostetler NAD trend reports. The NAD handles approximately 150 cases annually with over 95% voluntary compliance rate.

How to Select the Right Market Research Partner

Choosing the wrong research partner for claim substantiation can be more dangerous than not researching at all.

Start by evaluating their regulatory expertise. Your partner needs deep knowledge of FTC guidelines, NAD procedures, and industry-specific regulations. They should speak the language of substantiation fluently and understand what types of evidence regulatory bodies accept. Ask about their experience defending claims during challenges. Any hesitation is a red flag.

Industry experience matters enormously too. A partner who’s substantiated claims in your specific sector understands the nuances of your regulatory environment and competitive landscape. They know which claims typically face challenges and how to structure research that pre-empts those challenges. Generic research firms often miss critical industry-specific requirements.

Regulations vary significantly by market, and your research partner needs infrastructure to conduct compliant studies wherever you sell. They should handle everything from recruitment to testing to documentation across multiple jurisdictions. Claim substantiation market research gets complicated fast in international markets.

Industry-Specific Applications of Claim Substantiation Market Research

Different industries face unique challenges when substantiating claims. Understanding these nuances helps you design research that actually protects you.

  • Pharmaceuticals and Healthcare Products face the most stringent requirements. Your claim substantiation market research needs clinical trials that meet FDA standards if you’re making drug claims. Even over-the-counter products require robust evidence. The bar is high because health claims directly impact consumer safety.
  • 食品与饮品 companies navigate a minefield of nutrition and health claims. Structure-function claims require one level of proof, while disease prevention claims trigger drug classification. Your claim substantiation market research must carefully distinguish between these categories. Sensory claims like “best-tasting” need proper blind taste testing with appropriate controls. “Natural” claims face increasing scrutiny and require documentation of every ingredient source.
  • Cosmetics and Personal Care brands make claims about appearance, performance, and ingredients. “Dermatologist-tested” requires specific testing protocols. “Clinical results” demands proper clinical studies, not just consumer satisfaction surveys. Anti-aging claims are particularly sensitive—you need claim substantiation market research showing measurable improvements using standardized assessment methods. Before-and-after photos require proper controls to ensure results aren’t misleading.
  • 膳食补充剂 operate in a regulatory gray zone that makes substantiation critical. While you can’t make disease claims without FDA approval, you can make structure-function claims with proper substantiation. Your claim substantiation market research should document that claims are truthful and not misleading, even if not required to be pre-approved.
  • Technology and Electronics face substantiation challenges around performance specifications. Battery life claims need testing under realistic use conditions. Speed comparisons require controlled environments that isolate your product’s performance. “Award-winning” claims need documentation of legitimate awards from recognized organizations.
  • 金融服务 must substantiate return claims, fee comparisons, and performance projections. Historical data alone isn’t sufficient—you need to explain assumptions and limitations. “Best rate” claims require documented price surveys with clear parameters. Your claim substantiation market research should address both the accuracy of numbers and the context in which they’re presented.
  • 汽车 claims about fuel efficiency, safety, and performance face intense scrutiny. EPA testing provides standardized data, but marketing claims must accurately represent that data. Comparative claims like “best-in-class” require defining your class clearly and substantiating superiority.

索赔证实市场研究中的机会

由于全球经济和新兴市场的高速增长,未来几年对索赔证实市场研究的潜在需求很高。

  • 随着消费者知识和健康意识的提高,对有科学证据支持的产品和服务的需求日益增加。
  • 技术发展使得市场研究变得更加简单,可以进行索赔证实市场研究。
  • 随着制药行业的扩张,越来越多的临床试验需要支持产品声明。
Claim Substantiation Research: Average Costs by Methodology

Claim Substantiation Research: Average Costs by Methodology

Cost Comparison Across Research Methods (USD)

FTC Civil Penalties

$53,088

Maximum penalty per violation for FTC Act violations, updated annually for inflation

Research Timeline

8-16 weeks

Average duration for consumer survey-based claim substantiation studies

Clinical Trial Timeline

12-24+ weeks

Typical timeframe for clinical efficacy studies with proper controls and analysis

Minimum Sample Size

1,000

Recommended minimum respondents for defensible quantitative claim substantiation

Data Sources: Cost estimates compiled from IntoTheMinds Market Research, Sortlist Research Pricing, NCBI Clinical Trial Budgets, 和 FTC Civil Penalty Updates. Costs represent industry averages and vary based on study complexity, sample size, geographic scope, and regulatory requirements. Clinical trial costs can increase significantly with longer study durations, larger participant pools, and specialized instrumentation requirements.

索赔证实市场研究中的挑战

  • Complex regulations: Market research firms may find it challenging to comply with all regulations due to the complexity and dynamism of the rules governing product claims.
  • Data privacy and security: Claim substantiation market research faces a significant difficulty in protecting sensitive data, which is especially important in the healthcare sector due to the high value placed on patient privacy.
  • Cost and time constraints: It might be difficult for market research firms to provide affordable claim substantiation services due to the time and money required to gather and analyze vast amounts of data.

在开展研究以支持其主张时,利用尖端技术在市场研究人员中越来越受欢迎。企业正在使用大数据和人工智能来收集和分析大量数据以支持其主张。现在,随着人工智能在数据分析领域的出现,进行此类研究变得更加容易,并且通过更定期更新的数据和每日分析覆盖更广泛的受众。

影响此类研究的其他因素如下:

  • Evidence-based claims: Businesses are under more pressure than ever to back up their claims with hard data, especially in highly regulated sectors like healthcare and finance.
  • Use of new analytical methods and technologies: The application of new analytic methods and technologies is rapidly becoming the norm in the field of claim substantiation market research.
  • Focus on ethical practices: Increased demand for market research that can deliver data to support claims transparently and ethically is a direct result of the growing importance that businesses are placing on transparency.
  • Growth of real-world evidence: Actual evidence is growing in importance in the field of claim substantiation market research. Instead of relying simply on the results of simulated or laboratory settings, companies are increasingly turning to real-world data to back up their claims.
AI Blog Banner

Case Study: Transforming Risk Into Market Leadership

A global personal care brand approached a crossroads. Their flagship anti-aging skincare line was losing market share to aggressive competitors making dramatic claims about wrinkle reduction and skin firmness. The marketing team wanted to respond with equally bold claims, but previous half-hearted claim substantiation market research left them vulnerable.

The company committed to comprehensive substantiation before launching its counter-offensive. They conducted a 12-week clinical study with 120 participants, using standardized facial imaging and dermatologist assessments. The claim substantiation market research included consumer perception studies to ensure their claims resonated with target audiences while remaining defensible.

Initial findings revealed something unexpected: their product performed better on skin texture and radiance than on wrinkle depth—different from what they'd been emphasizing. Instead of forcing unsupportable wrinkle claims, they pivoted their messaging to highlight "visibly smoother, more radiant skin in 8 weeks."

Our analysis of similar client projects shows that this strategic flexibility typically increases campaign effectiveness by 35-60% compared to pursuing predetermined claims regardless of evidence. In their experience with substantiation research across 200+ beauty products, findings often reveal unexpected benefits that become more compelling marketing angles than original claims.

The brand launched confidently with its substantiated claims, backed by published study results. When a competitor challenged their claims through NAD within three months, they provided comprehensive documentation that led to a rapid dismissal. Meanwhile, two competitors faced successful challenges to their more aggressive claims and had to pull their campaigns.

The result is measurable. The brand gained 8 percentage points of market share within 18 months while competitors stumbled. Their sales team leveraged the substantiation in retail negotiations, securing premium shelf placement. Most importantly, consumer trust scores increased significantly because shoppers could see the research backing the claims.

This means claim substantiation market research doesn't just prevent losses—it creates competitive advantages that translate directly to revenue. The company's investment in proper substantiation delivered returns far exceeding the research costs through increased sales, avoided legal costs, and strengthened brand positioning.


Note: While this story is based on real strategies employed in the industry, specific client details have been tweaked to respect confidentiality.

What Makes SIS International Research a Top Claim Substantiation Market Research Partner?

The combination of regulatory expertise, global reach, and practical business focus makes SIS International Research uniquely qualified to handle your most complex substantiation challenges. Here's what sets us apart:

  • Customized Approach to Your Specific Industry and Claims – Cookie-cutter methodologies fail in substantiation research because every industry faces different regulatory requirements and challenge patterns. SIS International Research designs claim substantiation market research specifically for your products, claims, and competitive environment.
  • 40+ Years of Global Research Experience Across 135+ Countries – We have worked with 70% of Fortune 500 companies, bringing enterprise-level rigor to every project. With 150+ employees and collaborators worldwide, they combine local market knowledge with consistent global standards.
  • Access to Global Databases for Precise Research Recruitment – Claim substantiation market research is only as good as your participant selection. SIS International Research's extensive databases enable precise recruitment matching your target demographics and usage patterns.
  • Rapid Turnaround Without Compromising Quality – We have streamlined processes that deliver defensible claim substantiation market research on aggressive timelines. We understand which methodological shortcuts create vulnerability and which accelerate results safely.
  • Affordable Research That Fits Diverse Budget Requirements – SIS International Research structures projects to deliver defensible results at price points that work for mid-market companies. We help you prioritize which claims need the most rigorous substantiation and where more efficient methodologies still meet requirements. Cost-effectiveness matters because you need to substantiate multiple claims across product portfolios, not just one flagship product.
  • End-to-End Management from Design Through Documentation – SIS International Research handles study design, regulatory compliance verification, participant recruitment, data collection, statistical analysis, and documentation. You get comprehensive reports that satisfy regulatory scrutiny without coordinating multiple vendors.
  • Strategic Guidance Beyond Data Delivery – SIS interprets findings in a business context, identifying alternative claims that might be more defensible or compelling. We have seen thousands of substantiation projects and know which results translate to market success versus which merely check compliance boxes.

我们的纽约工厂地址

纽约州纽约市东22街11号2楼 10010 电话:+1(212) 505-6805


关于 SIS 国际

SIS 国际 提供定量、定性和战略研究。我们提供决策所需的数据、工具、战略、报告和见解。我们还进行访谈、调查、焦点小组和其他市场研究方法和途径。 联系我们 为您的下一个市场研究项目提供帮助。

作者照片

露丝-斯坦纳特

SIS 国际研究与战略创始人兼首席执行官。她在战略规划和全球市场情报方面拥有 40 多年的专业知识,是帮助组织取得国际成功的值得信赖的全球领导者。

满怀信心地拓展全球业务。立即联系 SIS International!

与专家交谈